The List

Jonny Pelham: Optimism Over Despair comedy review – Dark and difficult hilarity

A conflicted set hamstrings genuinely well-crafted jokes and a cathartic story

Share:
Jonny Pelham: Optimism Over Despair comedy review – Dark and difficult hilarity

Jonny Pelham has some thoughts about comedy and how it intersects with trauma. To give some background, in 2019 Pelham brought Off Limits to the Fringe, a highly personal exploration of child sexual abuse. Things took off, leading to a Live At The Apollo special followed by a mental health crisis; because telling people you’re fine night after night clearly doesn’t mean you’re fine. 

Picture: Steve Ullathorne

Now Pelham is back to explore the aftermath. And given our collective obsession with sharing every detail of our life online, this is a timely show with important questions to ask. But it’s still dark stuff, and there’s a sense Pelham hasn’t yet made peace with that; he frequently comments on the set, live-assessing how jokes are landing. It’s a tact that gets old fast, particularly when the subject matter demands trust between audience and performer. It’s extra-frustrating because there’s a hilarious set in there, if only he’d trust himself to deliver it; perhaps it’s a bad night, or part of his schtick. But when the laughs do come (and come they do) they’re cathartic. This isn’t ever going to be a cosy hour of comedy, but Pelham’s thoughts are always going to be worth hearing. 

Jonny Pelham: Optimism Over Despair, Pleasance Courtyard, until 27 August, 6.50pm. 

↖ Back to all news